Single Family Home For Sale in Old Tappan, NJ

MLS# : 26019852

Street : 55 Cripplebush
Price : $1,395,000
Town : Old Tappan, NJ 07675
Annual Taxes : $15,094

PROPERTY DETAILS

# of Rooms : 10
Bedrooms : 4
Full Baths : 2
Half Baths : 1
Basement : Full, Unfinished
Garage : Detached, O/See Remk
Year Built : Pre 1900
Lot Size : Irregular
Style : Colonial
Exterior : Vinyl
Heat/Cool : Gas, Hot Air, Multi-Zone

PROPERTY DESCRIPTION

Attention land lovers & nature seekers: this is your once in a lifetime opportunity to own a supersized partial of land, over 2.5 acres that backs up to 10+ acres of watershed property, situated in one of the most sought-after towns in Bergen County with 2026 Blue-Ribbon schools & the #1 high school in NJ! Step into this suburban oasis with complete privacy & barely a neighbor in sight. The modern farmhouse was completely renovated with love to keep the historic integrity but showcase its new amenities. Lounge on the lemonade porch, running the entire width of the home & watch the town go by. Inside the sun-filled open floor plan offers formal living & dining rooms, a contemporary kitchen that flows into the family room with a large quartz island. Off the kitchen is a walk-in-pantry, playroom & powder room. Two 8' sliders open to the magnificent backyard making the indoor-outdoor living perfect for entertaining. The handmade handrails lead to the 2nd floor laundry, 3 bedrooms, one with a walk-in, & guest bath with custom vanity trough sink. The primary suite flaunts a wall of windows, private bath, & walk-in closet. Outside, the driveway gate reveals a 3-bay detached garage with an unfinished loft space above waiting to be transformed. This unique property has an abundant space to host a mini-homestead with chickens & goats & maple trees that were already tapped for syrup. Experience the best of country living with the convenience of suburbia! Owner is a licensed realtor.

Amenities

Life Style :

Close/Parks, Close/School, Close/Shopg, Close/Trans, Close/Wrshp

This listing is a courtesy of RE/MAX Signature Homes
201-660-9933 office, listing agent Michele La Tour

About Old Tappan, NJ Real Estate Market

A small borough located in Bergen County in New Jersey State, Old Tappan shares its boundaries with other boroughs like Pearl River, Tappan, Lake Tappan, Hackensack River and Harrington Park. The borough of Old Tappan covers an area of 4.16 square miles, while as many as 6,000 people are residents in this borough.

Old Tappan got affirmed as a borough under an act of the New Jersey Legislature in 1894. It is one of those 26 boroughs which were formed during the Boroughitis phenomenon that happened in Bergen County in the same year. Deriving its name from the Tappan tribe of Native Americans, Old Tappan has one of the only four confluence points in New Jersey, the 41-degree north and 74-degree west.

Old Tappan is a small town inhabited mostly by distant working professionals and retired people in small-sized homes across the small lanes of the town. There are four houses from the bygone era included in the National Register of Historic Places – Frederick Haring House, Teunis Haring House, Gerrit Haring House and Haring-DeWolf House. The town also has Old Tappan Golf Course located on DeWolf Road, one of the most prominent lanes, which has New Jersey houses. Other popular locations of the own include Stone Point Park, Oaks Park and Gallagher Field.
Population:  5,896
Total Housing Units:  2,027
Single Family Homes:  1,446
Apartments:  572
General Tax Rate (2025):  2.346%
Effective Tax Rate (2025):  1.785%
Compare To Other Towns

Old Tappan Market Indicators

PRICE INDEX

Average Price* (12mo):  $1,342,064
Homes Sold* (12mo):  44
PRICE INDEX
SINGLE FAMILY HOME SALES

Old Tappan, NJ
12 Month Moving Average


1 YR 2 YR 3 YR 5 YR 7 YR MAX
 

Download Full Home Sales Report

REAL ESTATE TAXES

General Tax Rate (2025):  2.346%
Effective Tax Rate (2025):  1.785%
GENRAL TAX RATE - Old Tappan, NJ



MADISON ADAMSTM

office: 201-760-1100
84 E Ridgewood Ave, Suite 201
Ridgewood, NJ 07450
201-760-1100 (office)
201-760-1102 (fax)

Contact Info

FOR APPOINTMENTS CONTACT


Sales Associate
917-863-6560 (cell)

Madisom Adams Sales Associate Cindy Chiashin Shih


Sales Associate
201-724-6913 (cell)

Madisom Adams Sales Associate Carmela Maggio


Managing Partner
Broker Associate
646-279-8233 (cell)

Madisom Adams Broker Associate Helena Lobo-Zagorski


Real estate inventory
Old Tappan
Homes : $1,349,000 - 3,925,000 13
Condos : -
Co-ops : -
Twnhs : $849,777 - 1,399,000 5
2-4 Fam : -
5+ Fam : -
Land : -
Rentals : $5,850 - 6,500 3
Mixd Use : -
Com S : -
Com L : -
Biz : -


Similar Listings in Old Tappan

The data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Madison Adams are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website.
NJMLS is the owner of the copyrights of the listing content displayed for IDX. The NJMLS Internet Data Exchange Logo is a service mark owned by the NJMLS, Inc. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: 06/08/2026 00:05 AM Source: New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. “©2026 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.”


General Tax Rate is used to determine the amount of real estate tax levied upon a particular property. This rate is used to compute the tax bill.

Effective Tax Rate is used to compare of one district to another district based on the assumption that all districts are at 100% valuation. This rate has been computed by the State of New Jersey Department of the Treasury using County Equalization Average Ratios. This rate is NOT to be used to compute the tax bill.

Data Source: US Census 2010, NJ MLS, State of New Jersey Department of the Treasury

(A) Start Address :
(B) End Address : Get Directions

Need More Info

First Name:
Last Name:
E-mail:
Tel:--
Message:
Join Madison Adams
Market Reports



Contact Us

Please read the Consumer Information Statement (CIS)


  

Madison AdamsTM

84 E Ridgewood Ave, Suite 201
Ridgewood, NJ 07450
201 760-1100 (office)
201 760-1102 (fax)
office@madisonadams.com